6 ISSUES FOR £6 Subscribe to Surrey Life today click here

No-fault clause: Why getting a divorce is not always easy

PUBLISHED: 14:15 19 July 2017

Archant

In the absence of a no-fault clause getting a divorce is not always easy

George Bernard Shaw is reputed to have said “Marriage is an alliance entered into by a man who can’t sleep with the window open and a woman who can’t sleep with the window shut”. For some spouses, such issues are part and parcel of a normal marriage but for those who have been married a long time, there can be any number of reasons why a husband or wife may decide that they no longer wish to be together.

There are about 110,000 divorces in this country every year, and that is about 600 people who get divorced every day. Every divorce is based on an irretrievable marriage breakdown but this has to be proved by one of five different facts. Three of those facts are time related, including being separated for two years for a divorce by consent or being separated for five years with no consent required. However if a couple want to start divorce proceedings within the two year period, then they must use what is called a ‘fault based ground’, which means either citing the other party’s unreasonable behaviour or their adultery within the last six months.

The divorce legislation was brought into statute in 1973 and is now therefore over 43 years old and society has changed a lot in that time. Just about three quarters of all divorces today are based on a fault ground, with the majority being based on the other spouse’s unreasonable behaviour. The divorce itself can be a relatively simple paper process and the court costs for divorce proceedings from start to finish are £550.00. The government are also making the process easier by encouraging the filing of online petitions and simplifying the documentation.

The process however, has not been so straightforward, simple or inexpensive for Mrs Tini Owens, who at a recent court of appeal hearing lost her case to be divorced from her husband on the basis of his unreasonable behaviour. In this high profile case, which has received significant press attention, Hugh Owens decided - regardless of the fact they had been separated since February 2015 - that the marriage had not broken down, or at least not on the basis of the facts set out by Mrs Owens. These included not providing her with love, attention and affection and there being frequent and distressing arguments.

Unusually, Mr Owens decided to defend the divorce proceedings and perhaps even more unusually, the judge in London agreed with him, despite the amended petition containing 27 specific allegations of the husband’s unreasonable behaviour. The judge complained that the petition was hopeless, was scraping the barrel and lacked beef. He thought that the wife had exaggerated the context and gravity of the husband’s behaviour and ordered substantial costs against her.

Regrettably the Court of Appeal’s hands were tied because of the limitations in what they could do on appeal. Handing down his judgment, Sir James Munby asked himself the question as to whether the law was in a remotely satisfactory condition. He clearly thought not when he later noted that it was hypocritical when spouses and their family lawyers still have to use fault based grounds to progress divorces.

It is against most specialist family lawyers’ code of conduct to be inflammatory and to encourage conflict and confrontation, but this essentially seems to be the outcome of the Owens’ case. Mrs Owens has now taken her divorce to the Supreme Court and it is to be hoped that reason will prevail, and that she will not have to wait until she is 70 years old and there has been a five year separation before she can divorce and sort out the finances.

Many other countries including America and Australia have no fault divorce and it is surely time that England follows suit. As Neil Sedaka sang in 1975, breaking up is hard to do. And as this case proves, for some the current law can make it even harder.

For advice on the full range of family law issues please contact the Guildford office of Penningtons Manches LLP on 01483 791800 or visit penningtons.co.uk

More from Surrey Life

Yesterday, 16:17

As the Runnymede Rivers Celebration got under way, Rebecca Younger visited a hotel right at the heart of the action

Read more
Yesterday, 11:38

Great things to do in Surrey this weekend: art exhibitions, walks, concerts, theatre, places to visit and other events and ideas.

Read more
Friday, July 13, 2018

We’ve teamed up with Naturalmat to offer one lucky reader the chance to win a duvet and pillow collection worth £225

Read more
Friday, July 13, 2018

Surrey is England’s most wooded county and the Surrey Hills boasts almost 40 per cent woodland cover. These woodlands hide a wealth of archaeological features. We pick some of the best woodland walks to explore

Read more
Friday, July 13, 2018

We round up 10 of the most beautiful photos of Surrey shared on Instagram this week…

Read more
Thursday, July 12, 2018

If your skin is loose, developing deep lines, sagging or creating the appearance of jowls you may be a good candidate for the Concept™ Facelift. This type of facelift surgery is unique as the procedure is performed under local anaesthetic, and is far less invasive than traditional methods, meaning the procedure requires minimal down time.

Read more
Tuesday, July 10, 2018

Surrey villages are some of the most beautiful in Britain – think red-bricked cottages, cosy pubs, village greens and picture-worthy streets. We picked 14 of the prettiest Surrey villages to live.

Read more
Monday, July 9, 2018

President of the Reigate-based English Arts Chorale and former King’s Singer Brian Kay conducted Britten’s War Requiem at Winchester Cathedral

Read more
Monday, July 9, 2018

Enjoy a 4 mile (6.5km) walk around this little known area of Surrey

Read more
Monday, July 9, 2018

With beautiful countryside, stunning villages and plenty of bluebells during spring, Surrey is an amazing place for a stroll

Read more
Thursday, July 5, 2018

As the weather hots up give your look a modern boho twist

Read more
Tuesday, July 3, 2018

We take a look at some of the best places to visit in Chertsey

Read more
Tuesday, July 3, 2018

Mike Read dabbled in estate agency before finding on-air fame. The former BBC Radio 1 Breakfast Show presenter chats about how his call to the airwaves came at a Surrey cricket match and how he’s now commemorating Surrey greats with prestigious blue plaques

Read more
Tuesday, July 3, 2018

One of the biggest foodie events in the Surrey calendar is back for 2018! Voting is open and this year’s event will take place at G Live, Guildford on Thursday 13 September 2018

Read more
 
Great British Holidays advert link

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy


Topics of Interest

Food and Drink Directory

Subscribe or buy a mag today

subscription ad

Local Business Directory

Surrey's trusted business finder

Job search in your local area



Property Search