<div style="display:inline;"> <img height="1" width="1" style="border-style:none;" alt="" src="//googleads.g.doubleclick.net/pagead/viewthroughconversion/1028731116/?value=0&amp;guid=ON&amp;script=0">
6 ISSUES FOR £6 Subscribe to Surrey Life today click here

BBQ Whisky Beer at The White Hart, Witley GU8 5PH - restaurant review

PUBLISHED: 21:28 26 February 2015 | UPDATED: 15:22 24 March 2015

Many will have passed The White Hart without realising the magic inside

Many will have passed The White Hart without realising the magic inside


Award-winning ribs by a London institution that’s escaped to the country? Matthew Williams couldn’t resist a visit to The White Hart in Witley following 
a reader’s recommendation – and was pleased with what he found

It's no real suprise the rib's an award-winner - the chargrilled outer hides melt in the mouth goodness (Photo: Matthew Williams) It's no real suprise the rib's an award-winner - the chargrilled outer hides melt in the mouth goodness (Photo: Matthew Williams)

Originally published in Surrey Life magazine February 2015


Restaurant reviewed: BBQ Whisky Beer at The White Hart, Petworth Road, Witley, near Godalming GU8 5PH. Tel: 01428 683695


The low-down



Food: 9

Venue: 8

Service: 8

What we ate:


Beef Rillette, cranberry and toast, £7

Hot smoked trout, fried avocado and wasabi cream, £7

Main courses

Jacobs Ladder beef rib (large), £15

Sausages, £10

Triple-cooked chips, £3.50

Macaroni cheese with Parmesan and herb crumb, £4


Old-fashioned cheesecake, £6


Le Sanglier De La Montagne Reserve Chardonnay, £5

Twickenham Fine Ales’ Winter Cheer, £3.90

Hot Dark and Stormy (half pint), £2.50



REVIEW: It all started a few months ago when a reader got in touch to tell me they’d discovered a hidden gem in Witley.

“You must be talking about the ballroom under the lake, right?” I replied.

“Sorry, no, what’s that? A subterranean dancehall? Pretty sure this place is above ground – at least from what I remember; although they do serve an awful lot of whisky...” he added hesitantly.

Certainly, in the past, the most exciting thing I knew about the village of Witley, near Godalming, was that once upon a time a local eccentric had created a majestic country estate at Witley Park that included a glass ceilinged ballroom under its lake (read our piece HERE).

Now, while the reader’s suggestion may not have been quite as grand, to me it sounded equally intriguing: a new concept at The White Hart pub involving a modern twist on the traditional barbecue. And whisky; lots of it.

A few months went by with this exciting ‘new’ venture top of my must-visit list, but as keen-eyed readers may have spotted, my pen failed to touch these restaurant review pages for a while. It wasn’t for lack of interest; life, as they say, had chosen another path for me – and our review team of my wife Sylviane and I had expanded to three, with the addition of our beautiful daughter, Iona.

With fatherhood new to me, the thought of heading to any pub or restaurant seemed rather daunting. But, with no idea of the etiquette of family dining, we decided it was time to finally step back into the water.

Plus, as this latest venture at The White Hart came about from a husband-and-wife team leaving the crazy nights of London for the more sedate pace of the Surrey countryside with their two children, it seemed a fitting place to test our daughter’s patience – would we even make it to the starters though, I wondered?

Sam Daffin and his wife Fiona made their name at The Wargrave Arms near Edgware Road. Serving modern barbecue, with influences from Korean gogigui, American pits, Spanish plancha, Argentine asado and the good old-fashioned British grill, they went on to take the trophy for Great British Rib Champion at Ribstock 2013. But, back in leafy Surrey, how would this translate to a sprawling 16th century country pub? We were about to find out...

Heating up

Arriving at The White Hart, we were led out of the early 2015 cold to a window-side table with plenty of room for Iona and her pushchair. Among the cosy nooks, crannies and wood beams, whisky bottles decorated the shelves and records lined the walls, while blues and jazz floated out of the speakers.

With a small glass of wine, a hot dark and stormy (basically rum and ginger beer warmed to a mulled wine effect) and jug of water ordered (those 50 or so bottles of whisky would have to wait for another day!), I glanced around noting the mixed crowd of families with children and happy couples snuggled in quiet corners.

The menu at The White Hart is short and intense. You won’t find any ham and egg or fish and chips here; instead, it’s mainly slow-cooked barbecue meats (although there are also vegetarian dishes on offer) accompanied by wasabi creams, kimchee (a Korean side dish) and pickled salads.

For the starter, I opted for the hot smoked trout, which came with crunch from fried avocado and bite from wasabi cream. Presented with finesse, everything on the plate packed a perfect punch. Sylviane’s beef rillette arrived with cranberry sauce and toast. Her uncertainty over the cranberry was quickly won over by her first taste of the dish. Iona watched on enviously.

On to the main courses and I couldn’t resist the Jacob’s Ladder beef rib (which comes in three sizes). To accompany it, I ordered a pint of Twickenham Fine Ales’ Winter Cheer – not that the melt-off-the bone meat needed any help. Massaged with flavour, smoked on-site and cooked low and slow, this award-winning dish was a personal foodie heaven. With a pickled salad to freshen the palate and sides of triple-cooked chips and silky mac’n’cheese that made me finally realise why people like the stuff, this was knock-out fare.

Sylviane went for the sausages. Sounds simple, but these “angel hot guts” are a Texan-style sausage made with beef, pepper, paprika and beer. Handmade and again smoked on-site, they are finished over the charcoal grill and utterly delicious.

Already won over, we ummed and ahhed over dessert, but couldn’t resist the cheesecake. Served deconstructed in a jar, this variant took on the flavours almost of a cocktail: all vanilla cheesecake cream with bourbon caramel, cherries and orange bitters syrup. Sylviane, not normally a cheesecake fan, stole the jar.

Meeting Sam and Fiona, we were won over by their enthusiasm and passion. Transforming an English country pub in Surrey into a whisky and rib house was never going to be the easiest task, but I for one am pleased to see another unique venue sprinkling its own particular magic on the local foodie scene. The place was also bustling, so word is obviously out.

And Iona’s thoughts? She can’t wait to head back to try some of the good stuff – and take advantage of the conveniently placed high chairs on offer!

It may not be a ballroom under a lake, but The White Hart has all the ingredients to get Surrey society talking.


3 other restaurants doing the unusual

The Pendleton

St John’s, Redhill RH1 6QF

Tel: 01737 760212

With a refined restaurant menu always on offer, it still doesn’t take much to persuade chef Jon Coomb out of the kitchen to cook a giant paella outdoors or into their taco van for some Mexican flavours.


The Black Swan

Ockham KT11 1NG

Tel: 01932 862364

Visit The Black Swan at the right time and you’re sure to find some really interesting game on the menu. Well worth a visit at any time, be sure to ask for something a little different.


The Percy Arms

Chilworth GU4 8NP

Tel: 01483 561765

Serving modern British cuisine with a South African twist, among the intriguing options is the bobotie (ground beef steak seasoned with spices, baked with an egg topping and served with rice).


Welcome , please leave your message below.

Optional - JPG files only
Optional - MP3 files only
Optional - 3GP, AVI, MOV, MPG or WMV files

Please log in to leave a comment and share your views with other Surrey visitors.

We enable people to post comments with the aim of encouraging open debate.

Only people who register and sign up to our terms and conditions can post comments. These terms and conditions explain our house rules and legal guidelines.

Comments are not edited by Surrey staff prior to publication but may be automatically filtered.

If you have a complaint about a comment please contact us by clicking on the Report This Comment button next to the comment.

Not a member yet?

Register to create your own unique Surrey account for free.

Signing up is free, quick and easy and offers you the chance to add comments, personalise the site with local information picked just for you, and more.

Sign up now

More from Food & Drink

Wed, 15:25

January 25 marks Burns Night; an evening celebration of the great late Scottish poet Robert Burns. Many venues in Surrey will be hosting an array of celebrations to mark this cultural tradition, with more than enough haggis to go around. We pick our top events taking place in 2018

Read more
Mon, 13:15

Jenna Elsby from Chapel Lane events talks us through this recipe for Pink Peppercorn & Rosemary Crusted Fillet of Beef - a perfect dish for dinner parties with enough for leftovers.

Read more
Tuesday, January 9, 2018

Whether you enjoy a classic gin and tonic, a shaken not stirred martini or something altogether more adventurous, there’s never been a better time to be a lover of all things gin in Surrey. Here’s a selection of the best distilleries, from world conquering to exceedingly micro, on our doorstep

Read more
Monday, January 8, 2018

It’s been there or thereabouts on Surrey Life’s must-visit list for so long that the only surprise is what took us this long. Matthew Williams settles into Esher’s The Swan Inn, hot on the heels of their Tom Kerridge supper club

Read more
Tuesday, December 19, 2017

To many, building a kitchen in a glass box might be considered one of the first signs of madness. When Surrey Life caught up with super chef Steve Drake in January, however, that was exactly what he was planning. He got his wish. Matthew Williams grabs a table at his new restaurant, Sorrel

Read more
Monday, December 18, 2017

Gather your friends for a Moroccan inspired lunch

Read more
Tuesday, December 12, 2017

Surrey’s oldest French restaurant, La Barbe in Reigate, celebrated its 35th anniversary this year. As part of the birthday celebrations, La Barbe has created this recipe for Marquise au Chocolat; a French classic perfect for celebration dinners

Read more
Friday, December 8, 2017

From ancient hostelries with roaring inglenook fireplaces to craft- beer bars and whisky havens with a twist, Surrey is blessed with some truly tantalising pubs for a cosy winter lunch or leisurely couple of drinks. We pick 29 of the best

Read more
Thursday, November 30, 2017

With the light falling just right, you can imagine yourself in Tuscany when at Beaverbrook. While the setting is European, their Dining Room whisks you to the Land of the Rising Sun. Matthew Williams visits

Read more
Monday, November 20, 2017

With the festive season fast approaching, in no particular order we pick 10 of the best butchers in Surrey to pick up your turkey this Christmas

Read more
Monday, November 6, 2017

We pick some of the best places in Surrey to enjoy a festive take on the quintessential English tradition of afternoon tea at Christmas

Read more
Wednesday, October 18, 2017

Dark and chilly winter evenings are perfect for huddling in the corner of a country pub with friends, catching up over beer and supper in front of a log fire. Surrey is home to cosy pubs a-plenty – here are ten of the top places to go…

Read more
Wednesday, October 18, 2017

When one Surrey pub group were looking for a new wine to set them apart from the crowd, their search led to the gates of the family-owned Château Carbonneau near Bordeaux. More than one year on, it’s a relationship which continues to blossom

Read more
Thursday, October 12, 2017

Having coordinated Surrey’s first Goatober campaign in Dorking last year, The Salt Box has teamed up with the Stone House Vinyl Café to bring the event to Reigate in October 2017

Read more
Great British Holidays advert link

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Subscribe or buy a mag today

subscription ad
Surrey Life Application Link

Local Business Directory

Surrey's trusted business finder

Job search in your local area

Property Search